<p>This paper presents an interesting topic, which can potentially generate a very valuable theoretical debate for the discipline. However, the theoretical review is limited to exemplify why, in the opinion of the author(s), the evolutionary theory is weak. In that sense, it is not clear if the objective of the article is to criticize the foundation of evolutionary psychology, or the theory of evolution itself (which would be equally valid). The title suggests the former, but the body of the paper appears to address the latter.</p><p>In future versions, it would be very interesting to expand the review of the literature, to include the broad theoretical body existing in the subject, both for and against the theory of evolution, and put this debate in the reader's perspective. In the present version, this debate is not fully appreciated, since the emphasis has been on how evolutionary theory fails in the opinion of the author(s), illustrating these flaws with several examples. This, although valuable, limits the opportunity to appreciate the original theoretical contribution of the present study.</p>